I'm no fan of the Today programme. Once it was genuinely the flagship news programme of the nation. Now it has dissapeared so far up its own behind that it speaks total...
The latest row is about the BBC pulling an interview by the Archbishop of Canterbury. Lambeth Palace aides were repordly furious because John Humphries breached an agreement not to question Rowan Williams about the Iraq war.
The question being asked is was the BBC right to do this (Humphries was furious and threatend to quit). My professional PR opinion is that it depends on the agreement. If Today had agreed with the Lambeth Palace PRs not to mention the war then it is a serious breach of ethics to do so. Therefore the BBC was right to pull the interview.
I've dealt with Today and they are a pain in the butt. Arrogant beyond belief. Other broadcasters (including other BBC news outlets) usually play an honest bat. Not so Today.
When I was representing a personal injury law firm I remember Today tracking down the families of children who had died of CJD. More than 20 families were involved in the court case, most of whom were willing to talk to the press, a few who wouldn't. Every other newspaper and broadcaster respected our wishes and only tried to interview the families we gave them. Not so Today, who harrassed distressed people with late night and early morning phone calls to pressurise them into talking.
Its about four years since I worked on PR for personal injury lawyers but I'm working on a pitch to one at the moment. It's the most exciting brief I've had since setting up my own business. It's impossible not to be moved by the fact that your PR campaign is actually having a real, direct, positive impact on people's live.