A PR Guru's Musings is now at www.stuartbruce.biz
 



A PR Guru's Musings is now at www.stuartbruce.biz
  Home
    Unfiled
    Feed Options
    Self Promotion
    Random Musings
    Business
    Business Podcasting
    Good PR Ideas
    Community PR
    Northern Business
    Technology
    Business Blogging
    Public Relations
  About
  Archives
  Guestbook
  Contacts
 


 
Links
   Click here for other web feed options such as My Yahoo
   A PR Guru's Musings Blog

http://20six.co.uk/stuartbruce

powered by
20six.co.uk



 

Do you always need to give credit for blog posts?

Two things in the last couple of days have made wonder about blogging ettiquette. And today Allan Jenkins at Desirable Roasted Coffee blogs on the same theme.


Yesterday I wrote about Gary Stein of Jupiter Media and how he was predicting that blogs and traditional websites would become one. That's exactly what I had talked about during my presentation at the University of Sunderland Making the News conference. That's why I wrote about it.


A bit later I was reading my feeds and came across a post by Steve Rubel that referenced the same Gary Stein article. So I updated my previous post with a link to Steve's Micropersuasion blog saying he had disagreed with both of us. The trackback that I sent hasn't yet appeared on Steve's blog - perhaps it's stuck in Steve's moderation queue?


Allan's concern was with a new blog by Robert J Ricci, a Weber Shandwick employee. Robert blogged about Google Analytics being illegal in Europe. But the problem was that Fredrik Wackå has said the same thing the day before and Robert hadn't referenced him. I actually posted on the same topic and did reference Fredrik, but it was on the Let's talk business blog, which I help to run for my client Softalk.


You see I'm not so sure it is so big a faux pas anymore. As the number of blogs grows and grows you are not going to be reading every single one. Even if you use tools to monitor keywords and themes you're not always going to know what other people have written.


I don't sit down and read all my feeds before I blog. As a result I'll admit I've written some posts that are mighty similar to ones that other people have already written. And not given them credit, but to any third party looking at the content and the timing of the posts it would appear my inspiration was actually plagiarism.


I guess the lesson is that we've all got to learn both the new rules of the blogging game (as they actually emerge) and to be more tolerant and supportive of those that are still learning.

22.11.05 19:15
 


To date 6 Comment(s)     TrackBack-URL


Steven Silvers / Website (23.11.05 03:38)
Stuart... I too wrote something similar as your comments earlier this month. I pointed to a blog ad revenue study and suggested that it underscored how the profit motive will force many stand-alone blogs to evolve upward into full-featured web sites.
I'm assuming that with, what, maybe a bazillion blogs out there we might two or three execuflacks writing about the same thing at the same time. You think?
(Oh, and we're right, you and me.)
Cheers.
steve
www.stevensilvers.com


Allan Jenkins / Website (23.11.05 07:33)
Faux pas? Maybe not. It's certainly rude.
I count a number of PR bloggers -- including some on your blogroll -- as friends. Friends and, in some cases, mentors. Not to credit them would be to make a serious raid on my karma account.
Leaving "nice" aside, credit, linking, and trackbacks leave a useful trail for the reader to follow. I've found countless useful posts I would have missed if the blogger had not helpfully provided clues to his inspiration.
Sure, we are inspired by many sources; I'm not suggesting we attach a bibliography to every post. And I don't think it's necessary to link my "Sony's PR woes" posts to every other blog that's posted on the same issue.
But when one of us obviously and openly lifts an idea -- and we all know it -- it's just rudeness.


Elizabeth Albrycht / Website (23.11.05 09:57)
Attribution is one of the topics we've been discussing amongst ourselves at the Society for New Communications Research as a potential topic for our work. It is indeed challenging, and I have had the same experience, both in terms of writing similar things at the same time as others (without being aware of their writing) and writing ideas that seem to come to me via osmosis after reading zillions of blogs -- and I can't remember, nor can I find, the original post (and believe, me, I search!). My rule of thumb is to attribute where I can, and acknowledge that the idea came somewhere when I don't remember (and ask others to point to the reference if they know it).


Kevin Dugan / Website (25.11.05 03:24)
It's tough to be completely exhaustive, but I always try and attribute with a link/trackback. Is it possible for someone to post on the same topic, shortly after you, without having seen your post? Sure. If the person is new and I am not aware of them, I give them the benefit of the doubt. If it is someone I know reads my blog, as we have exchanged comments, not so much. In the long run, it works against the person doing it.


(25.11.05 08:29)
I partially agree with Kevin. That's what you should do. But it is the practicality of doing it that I've got a problem with. We are all under the pressure of time and I don't see how as the blogosphere continues to grow that you can keep up this "rule".
I subscribe to about 500 feeds. I only actually visit about 10 blogs regularly. There are blogs that I've exchanged comments with where I could easily miss a post. Also if you've already posted it all takes extra time to go back and add links/trackbacks after you spot the other mention that was actually posted before yours.


John23 / Website (23.5.07 15:25)
otos stand lesbisk |plc| leikkeet xnxx upskirt |plc| lesbisk erotiknoveller porno |plc| slavesex peraaukon orgasmi |plc| sperm troath leike |plc| fetis avsugning taxi |plc| ihastuttava amatoori toiminta |plc| piesexni nusex sexsi |plc| naken tantrinen portto |plc| seksia takapuoleen orgasmi |plc| imeminen leike porno |plc| penis perverssi puusanky |plc| koti popon |plc| huora sexe porno |plc| maksuton milf lessons |plc| tonaring nuori ilmasto |plc| ujo amatoori video |plc| imaisu livesexlist orgasmi |plc| pettymys imaisu masturbating |plc| fetis adelina leikkeet |plc|

Name:
Email:
Website:
Email me when further comments are posted
Save information (cookie)



 Insert emoticons



The weblog's authors are responsible for the contents of this blog. Your free weblog from 20six.co.uk